Deciding the best way to end a story is, for me, like filing my taxes. I know I need to do it, but I put it off and put it off until I just slap something together in a mad dash at the last minute. I don’t feel good about it, and I just hope no one notices how half-baked it is. (Hello, IRS!)
Endings are hard. Hemingway famously wrote 47 endings to A Farewell to Arms, and when asked the reason for so many different endings, he told interviewer George Plimpton, “Getting the words right.” Getting the words right means fulfilling the promise set at the beginning of the story and leaving the reader satisfied. We want the pace and tone in the conclusion to complement the rest of the story. This is probably one of the most difficult aspects of writing a novel, yet one that is discussed the least.
There are six main ways to conclude your story. Let’s look at each option so that whether you’re a pantser or a plotter, you’ll feel good about writing The End.
Resolved Ending
This type of ending is perfect when you want all plot points and story questions to be settled. Readers will know what happens to all of the characters and have a small sense of what’s next for them, e.g. living happily ever after. Some genres lend themselves to this kind of ending. Mysteries, suspense thrillers, romance, and children’s lit come to mind right away. Imagine coming to the end of Murder on the Orient Express and not learning who the culprits are and how they did it.
Hint: The characters don’t necessarily need to be happy about how things turned out!
Unresolved Ending
This option is most often used to set up a sequel. Think of the Harry Potter series or the Star Wars saga. Major, overarching plot points remain open and characters are still on their journeys, even as the book comes to a close. The ending usually reminds readers about the conflict that still looms large to entice them to pick up the next book in the series. In other words, the ending creates a sense of anticipation rather than resolution.
Hint: Readers still want to feel satisfied at the ending while being excited about what happens next.
Implied Ending
Maybe you don’t want your novel to have a tied-up-with-a-bow ending. You’d rather not state explicitly what happens, preferring to let readers come to their own conclusions about certain plot points or how the characters ultimately fare. One example that comes to mind is Life of Pi by Yann Martel. With this ending, you’ll need to set up the story arc so that there is more than one feasible explanation to the main plot question. Then, and here’s the tricky part, you must back off from providing the answer.
Hint: This is a delicate balance. Don’t leave readers feeling cheated or confused.
Twist Ending
This ending catches readers off guard with an unexpected turn of events. Usually the characters (and the readers) learn that something they believed to be true is false: A character isn’t dead, the hero is the villain (or vice versa), or vital information is uncovered. Twists are dramatic shifts within the last few pages of a novel, playing with readers’ emotions. Atonement by Ian McEwan and Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn are great examples of novels with twist endings that have readers replaying the novel events and changing their understanding of those events.
Hint: This doesn’t mean the ending is unrealistic or cliche. It still needs to make sense based on the characters’ personalities and the framework of the story.
Mirror Ending
This type of ending can occur one of two ways. First, when using a retrospective narrator who is telling readers the story from a point in the future, the last scene brings readers back to the start of the story in a full circle. Think about the movie Titanic. Elderly Rose starts and ends her story on the modern ship. The middle of the story about her experience on the Titanic is one long flashback.) Or, the last scene can simply take place in the same setting echoing the first scene. The mirror ending creates framework of balance and symmetry for the story, allowing readers to better understand the emotional journey the character has made.
Hint: Take care to make sure the suspense isn’t deflated from the bulk of the story by hints at the outcome.
Crystal Ball Ending
More than the other endings, this one looks into the future, explaining what happens to the characters months or years later. The “where are they now” ending is most commonly handled through an epilogue. For example, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows concludes the series with an epilogue set 19 years after the main story. Readers may want to know what happens to the main characters and how their lives turn out after the story ends, but it may leave them disappointed if the epilogue is rushed and lacks emotional magnitude.
Hint: Don’t use this ending to resolve the narrative arc, only to project into the future.
Next time: Tips to troubleshoot bad endings!
Some other posts you might enjoy:
I love your categories for the types of endings. Do you have any thoughts on the trend to move away from “resolved” endings in current fiction? I know I’m speaking in generalities here, but I’ve noticed this pattern and it leaves me feeling unsatisfied at the end of the book. This must be intentional–on the author’s part. But why leave readers dangling and unhappy?
Hi Patti, You make a great point about the trend in fiction to steer away from resolved endings toward more unresolved endings. Many writers don’t want to provide a tidy ending. They want to let the reader come to her own conclusion about what it all means. The problem can come in when writers confuse an unresolved ending with a confusing ending. An ending can be clear and still be open to interpretation. That said, I do tend to prefer resolved endings too! 😉
Hi Jackie,
Loved the Hemingway factoid since without the winning prose the plot doesn’t work, at least for me. You’re so right about Jacqueline Woodson’s terrific video on getting and receiving feedback that’s instructive from people you love and trust. As for Patti’s comments, I loved MY OXFORD YEAR by Julia Whalen in which the ending is left open. In this case, because of the nature of the romance, I think the reader is OK not knowing fearing the ending might not be a happy one, plus it felt more realistic. I won’t explain more should you or your readership read the novel, already in the works for a movie. Finally, on my shelf is what you’re currently reading — EVERYONE BRAVE IS FORGIVEN and one of your other recommendations, SOURDOUGH, is sitting on my Kindle! It’s a bit overwhelming how many books are being published, awaiting, but aren’t we lucky to have them and love reading. Lorraine
Hi Lorraine, That’s a great point about the open/unresolved ending feeling more realistic. We feel like we’re peeking into the lives of these characters for a short period and then leaving them.
There are so many good books to read and so little time! I hope you enjoy both of these novels as much as I did. SOURDOUGH is quirky and fun, perfect for a light summer read.
Another great post, Jackie. It’s interesting to visually ‘see’ these ending types and think about the reactions of those in my book club. I am clearly the only fan of the implied ending. Ha ha. Most everyone else likes that tidy bow at the end. Not me!
Thank you, Melissa! Ha! I love that you’re a fan of the unresolved ending. 🙂
If there are too many loose ends, I have an anxious feeling. I worry about what happened to the characters!
So interesting. That’s amazing about Hemingway.
I’m not a novelist, but I do read a lot and can’t stand endings that fall flat. It’s just like you said–they didn’t know what to write so they slapped something together. Kind of like looking forward to a great meal and getting gruel instead. 🙂
Ha! Gruel would definitely be a letdown! But I understand your point. After you spend hours and hours reading a book, you hope the end pays off. 🙂