Controversial topic alert! If you want to start a heated debate at your next writing group, ask if you should include a prologue in your novel. Many writers love prologues, but many readers (and therefore agents) aren’t keen on them. There’s no one-size-fits-all here, so let’s take look at both sides.
Before we get started…
What is a prologue?
A prologue is different from an author’s note, a preface, an epigraph, and a forward. A prologue acts as an introduction to your story, as a sort of appetizer to the main course that is your novel.
First let’s review some reasons to avoid a prologue.
Reasons not to include a prologue
- Many readers just skip them. I’m sorry to be the one to tell you this. In my completely unscientific poll of five avid readers, none read prologues. One reader said that he finds them to be more confusing than illuminating.
- You want to create “atmosphere.” Some writers (especially fantasy and science fiction writers) use the prologue to set the stage of the story. Why do we need a separate section for this? Setting and mood should be infused into each page of your novel, not something to prepare the reader for.
- The reader won’t understand the story without it. Often writers will tell me that they need to include a prologue for the following reasons:
- To “warm” up the reader
- To share details about a character’s past
- To explain the world of the story
- To provide historical context
None of the above reasons are solid enough on their own to give rise to a prologue. If the reader truly needs this information, why isn’t it in the main novel?
On other other hand…
Reasons to include a prologue
- Share critical information that occurred well outside the time frame of the main story. (Note the word critical.) It is usually not desirable to stop the forward momentum of your main story to include an event that happened in another era, likely with other characters. A prologue can present this information without distracting from the action in the present day.
- Foreshadow what is to come. While you wouldn’t want to include the novel’s inciting incident in the prologue, you can entice readers by hinting at the event or its aftermath.
- Introduce the villain. For those of you writing in genres with a clearly defined antagonist, the prologue can be a good place to introduce this character, showcasing the villain’s evilness or offering a glimpse into the villain’s humanity.
If you decide to include a prologue, keep these points in mind:
- Sharing too much background. A prologue isn’t the place to unleash all of the research that you were unable to shoehorn into the main story. You want to hook readers in the prologue to make sure they can’t stop turning the pages, but that brings us to the next pitfall…
- Including the inciting incident. The prologue should not contain the key moment that sends the main characters on their journey. Now, here is the tricky part—the prologue should move the story forward. It should have an impact on the main plot, but it shouldn’t be the moment that changes everything for the characters.
- It’s just too long. While there is no hard-and-fast rule about the length of a prologue, it’s time to re-evaluate if yours is beyond five pages. Readers will become impatient and want to start the story already.
- The prologue doesn’t fit the tone of the story. I’ve read prologues that feel as if they were lifted from another novel. Maybe the prologue language is poetic and flowery while the main novel is straight forward. Or the prologue introduces a character as contemplative while in the main novel he is snarky and sharp.
Questions to ask yourself
- What information am I providing to the reader? Is it necessary? Really necessary?
- What is the purpose of my prologue? What do I want the reader to take away from it?
- Why do I need to reveal these details separately? Could I include them within the main story?
Have you included a prologue in your novel? As a reader, how do you feel about prologues?
Before you go…
Starting January 2019! I am developing a 31-Day Editing Challenge as a helpful guide to get you off on the right foot as you edit your novel, memoir or short story. Whether you’re on your first draft or your fifth, we will explore the basics of developmental editing. My goal is to help you approach your manuscript in a new way and keep your momentum going. I hope you will be interested in joining me. It’s FREE! Learn more here and get on the list!